10 Best Pacifiers Moms are Talking About

Written by lara

Stock Up! Keep multiple pacifiers on hand—stash them in your home, car, and diaper bag. Having extras ensures you are always prepared, especially when one inevitably hits the floor or goes missing!

Explore Your Interest

 

The most prevalent type of pacifier in the United States dates back to the early 1900s and was created by Christian W. Meinecke, known then as a baby comforter.

Today, pacifiers come in various sizes, shapes, colours, and materials to suit various preferences. Despite these variations, their fundamental purpose remains consistent: to simulate the natural sucking action of babies and to soothe them between feedings or when they are distressed. 

Regarding soothing a fussy baby, pacifiers can be a lifesaver for parents. They offer comfort, help calm irritable infants, and might even reduce the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS), though research is still ongoing. 

However, pacifiers do have some potential downsides. Prolonged use can lead to dental issues like crossbites and overbites, to nipple confusion (particularly in breastfed babies) and may become a tough habit to break as the child gets older. Therefore, using pacifiers properly is key to reaping their benefits while minimising drawbacks.

As your child grows, their pacifier needs will change. It is important to choose pacifiers that support different stages of oral development. Our guide today features 10 of the best pacifiers for breastfed babies in 2024. These options provide comfort and promote healthy oral development, helping you make a well-informed choice.

Here's a Sneak Peek of our Best Pacifiers

How we Choose the Best Pacifiers

Finding the ideal pacifier for your breastfed baby can be quite a task. We have extensively searched online to compile a list of pacifiers highly recommended by parents. Factors such as cost, materials, ease of cleaning, shape, size, and ventilation were carefully considered to ensure our pacifier recommendations are perfect for your little one.

When selecting a pacifier for your baby, the most important factor is finding one they will accept and use comfortably. However, despite their similar appearances, there are significant differences among baby pacifiers available in the market. We also adhered to the American Academy of Pediatrics’ guidelines on pacifier safety and practical use. Some pacifiers came highly recommended by these experts, while others matched expert advice and received thousands of positive reviews from parents. 

Additionally, experts advise against overly complex pacifiers with attachments, like toys or plastic decorations, as these can detach and pose safety hazards.

We excluded any options that did not meet these safety recommendations to ensure we only featured the safest pacifiers. This approach prioritises both comfort and safety for your baby.

ID: bestone

Best Pacifier Overall

Philip AVENT Soothie Pacifier

Best Pacifier Overall
Retailer Image

Why we like it

  • Durable
  • Easy to clean
  • Soft nipple
  • Symmetrical shape for jaw and teeth development

Something to Note

  • The hold tab is minimal
  • Round shape means they can roll away if dropped
  • Traps moisture easily.

Customer’s Review

One mom recently shared how these pacifiers have been a total game-changer for her. She absolutely loves the fact that they have little holes that let you easily attach them to a pacifier keeper or leash, so you can clip it right onto your baby’s shirt. No more searching for lost pacifiers—how great is that? And the best part, she says, is that they can go through the dishwasher time and time again without becoming cloudy, cracking, or wearing down.

Another mom was equally impressed. She raved about their durability, saying she is tugged on them pretty hard herself, and they still didn’t rip or tear! One feature she particularly appreciated was the small hole on the outside of the nipple, which makes it super easy to help your baby position it just right. And with the one-piece design, she felt at ease knowing there were no small parts that could come apart.

ID: besttwo

Best Pacifier for Newborn

Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Silicone Pacifier

Best Pacifier for Newborn
Retailer Image

Why we like it

  • Curved design results in minimal skin contact.
  • Lightweight, making it easy for babies to hold in their mouths.
  • Dishwasher safe and easy to clean
  • Available in different colours

Something to Note

  • Some babies may not like shape
  • Slightly more expensive than some alternatives

Best for: Newborn, sleep, sensitive skin, 

Recommended ages: 0-6 months, 6-18 months, 18-36 months

Features: One-piece design, BPA free, orthodontic, 4 pack

Material Type: Silicone

Customer’s Review

Customer Review: A mom recently shared her experience about the Tommee Tippee pacifier—it has been a total game-changer for many! One mom could not stop talking about how it transformed nap times and nighttime routines. She loved its ultra-lightweight design, saying even the tiniest babies can keep it in their mouths longer. And, of course, that meant more sleep for her too—a real win for any sleep-deprived parent!

Another mom was equally impressed, particularly with its one-piece construction, which makes cleaning so much easier. She shared how she regularly checks them for wear and tear, but these pacifiers have held up incredibly well. In fact, after trying the Tommee Tippee, her baby wouldn’t go back to any other kind. Durable, easy to clean, and baby-approved—it’s a real crowd-pleaser!

ID: bestthree

Best Pacifier for Breastfed Babies

Nanobébé Flexy Pacifier

Best Pacifier for Breastfed Babies
Retailer Image

Why we like it

  • Soft, lightweight and ergonomic shape
  • Eliminate nipple confusion to calm and soothe your little one with ease
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Easiest to clean
  • It comes in affordable multipacks

Something to Note

  • There is no hole to attach a clip
  • Stage 2 is better for mobile babies
  • You may need to switch to a larger size sooner.

Best for: Breastfeed babies, teething, older babies 

Recommended ages: 0-3 months, 3-6 months, 4-36 months

Features: Award-winning best pacifier for breastfed babies, one-piece design, BPA free, phthalate-free, orthodontic, 2-pack, 

Material Type: Silicone

Customer’s Review

Customer Review: One mom’s journey to find the perfect pacifier for her newborn. After searching high and low, she finally discovered the Nanobebe Active Baby Pacifiers—and she could not be happier with her choice! The clever design of the pacifier mirrors the shape of the Nanobebe bottles her baby already adored, making the transition from bottle to pacifier an absolute breeze. Her baby instantly recognized the familiar shape and accepted it without hesitation.

Jonathan Rovnyak, a fellow mom of an infant, shared how much she appreciates the soft silicone construction. Unlike traditional plastic pacifiers, this one is super gentle on her baby’s delicate skin. The silicone conforms to the baby’s mouth, leaving no marks and staying comfortable for long stretches of time. The contoured shield ensures proper airflow, so there’s no irritation, while the orthodontic design supports healthy oral development.

Another big win is that the one-piece design offers peace of mind with no small parts that could pose a choking hazard. 

Also, the fact that the pacifiers and bottles are so consistent in design really simplifies their daily routine, making switching between the two effortless.

If you are on the lookout for a pacifier that not only meets your baby’s needs but also supports healthy development, the Nanobebe pacifiers might just be the perfect fit!

ID: bestfour

Best Pacifier for Bottle-fed Babies

Dr. Brown HappyPaci 100% Silicone Pacifier

Best Pacifier for Bottle-fed Babies
Retailer Image

Why we like it

  • Soft, lightweight,
  • Affordable
  • Designed to mimic Dr. Brown's bottle nipple shape and size
  • Dishwasher safe

Something to Note

  • Younger babies might struggle to keep this pacifier in their mouths due to its bulky design.
  • The elongated nipple may be challenging for very young babies to manage.
  • Its larger size is more appropriate for slightly older infants.

Best for: Bottle-fed babies, fussy babies, sleep.

Recommended ages: 0-6 months

Features: Contoured one-piece design, BPA-free, phthalate-free, 3-pack.

Material Type: 100% Silicone.

Customer’s Review

Customer Review

One mom, who was juggling food allergies and reflux with her baby, could not believe her luck when she stumbled upon Dr. Brown’s pacifier. After receiving one with a pack of Dr. Brown’s bottles, she quickly noticed her baby’s clear preference for it and did not waste any time ordering six more. For her, this pacifier was a total game-changer. Her baby, who usually needed a bottle to fall asleep, now dozed off peacefully with just the pacifier—no “snack” required. The seamless, one-piece silicone design made cleaning a breeze, but what she loved most was the large loop which makes the pacifier harder to drop, easy for her baby to hold and perfect for attaching to a pacifier strap.

Another mom had a similar success story. She was thrilled to discover that the claims on the packaging were spot on. This pacifier made transitioning between Dr. Brown’s bottles and pacifiers so much smoother. It easily fits into her baby’s feeding and sleeping routine without any fuss. If you are in search of a pacifier that works seamlessly with your baby’s feeding habits, this might just be your  new go-to.

ID: bestfive

Best Pacifier for Teething

Ryan and Rose Cutie PAT Pacifier and Teether

Best Pacifier for Teething
Retailer Image

Why we like it

  • Pacifier and a teether in one
  • Handle is a teething ring
  • Available in different colours
  • Attractive design
  • Dishwasher safe

Something to Note

  • Expensive
  • Nipple is thin
  • May be too large for babies

Best for: Babies without teeth, breastfeeding babies, oral development

Recommended ages: Stage 1 for babies without teeth, stage 2 for babies with teeth,

Features: One-piece design, BPA, PVC, latex, and phthalate-free.

Material Type: 100% medical grade silicone.

Customer’s Review

Customer Review

An infant mom shared her success story with the Ryan & Rose Cutie Pat starter pack, which comes with a variety of pacifier shapes. Her first son was instantly drawn to the flat style and absolutely adored it. She could not help but be impressed by the durability and quality of these pacifiers—especially since they held up even through the teething phase without showing any wear. And the best part? They were easy for her son’s tiny hands to grab, making life a little smoother for everyone.

Another mom had a different kind of success with her 4-month-old, who had suddenly started refusing pacifiers. She found the variety pack a lifesaver, letting her baby explore different shapes until they found the one she liked best. But the fun didn’t stop there—her little one loved playing with all the different styles and chewing on the teething handle, which was easy for her to hold. The sturdy material gave this mom peace of mind, knowing it would not break easily, and she was also thrilled with how it looked great and was easy to clean. 

ID: bestsix

Best Orthodontic

Chicco PhysioForma Silicone Pacifier

Best Orthodontic
Retailer Image

Why we like it

  • Comes with a carrying case
  • Developed by orthodontic experts
  • Easy to clean

Something to Note

  • Not dishwasher safe
  • It has a right and wrong side, which can sometimes be annoying to caregivers.
  • The material attracts lint and dirt.

Best for: Psychological breathing, oral development, sleep and providing comfort for breastfed babies

Recommended ages: 0-6 months, 6-16 months, 16-24 months

Features: One-piece design, BPA and latex-free, orthodontic nipple, 2- count in sterilising case

Material Type: 100% soft silicone

Customer’s Review

Customer Review

One mom discovered that these one-piece silicone pacifiers were a true game-changer for her petite daughter. Unlike pacifiers that mix plastic and silicone, these are crafted entirely from solid silicone, which makes them not only soft but also incredibly durable. She started using the infant size when her baby was just a few months old and later switched to the larger ones around 7 or 8 months. Since her little one is in the 1st percentile for height, the transition came a bit later than usual—most babies start using the larger size around 6 months. Still, the fit and comfort made this switch easy for her, and the durability kept her confident they will last.

Another mom, with an infant of her own, praised the simplicity of cleaning—just toss them into the steriliser and they are good to go! She also loved the loop design, which was perfect for attaching to a standard pacifier clip, helping to keep it from getting lost. Practical, durable, and loved by babies, these pacifiers quickly became her go-to.

ID: bestseven

Best Pacifier for Night

MAM Perfect Night

Best Pacifier for Night
Retailer Image

Why we like it

  • Glows in the dark
  • Reduces skin irritation
  • The symmetrical design let babies use it in any orientation.
  • The vented shield promotes airflow between the pacifier and the baby's face.

Something to Note

  • Flexible, thin and can break easily
  • Nipple traps water
  • The button design won't work on all pacifier clips

Best for: Night, toddlers, sensitive skin, 

Recommended ages: 16+ months 

Features:  100% free BPA and BPS, orthodontic, 2-count with a steriliser box, 

Material Type: Silicone

Customer’s Review

Customer Review: A mom of 2 can’t say enough about how these pacifiers have transformed her parenting life. She calls them “literal pieces of magic with reassurance built in.” After trying countless brands, this is the only one her babies will take. Initially, she was a bit sceptical of the glow-in-the-dark feature, but now she swears by it. She says it is a “genius” design and an absolute “game changer” when those inevitable nighttime searches for the pacifier begin. No more fumbling in the dark—just a soft glow to guide the way.

Another mom loves how these pacifiers fit perfectly and safely. She emphasizes the importance of sizing up as recommended to ensure the pacifier and bulb are just the right size for her baby’s mouth, without any worries about improper fit. Her final verdict? Extremely safe, and a product she highly recommends to other parents looking for peace of mind and functionality!

ID: besteight

Best Pacifier for Toddlers

NUK Comfy Orthodontic Pacifier

Best Pacifier for Toddlers
Retailer Image

Why we like it

  • Dishwasher safe
  • Glows in the dark
  • Beautiful designs
  • Heart shape for easy breathing
  • Affordable

Something to Note

  • Food and dirt can become trapped between the nipple and the shield.
  • May be too heavy for babies under 3 months

Best for: Toddlers, oral development

Recommended ages: 18-36 months

Features:  BPA free, orthodontic, 2 pack, 

Material Type: Silicone

Customer’s Review

Customer Review

A mom could not be more thrilled to have found what she calls an “absolute lifesaver” in these pacifiers. The glow-in-the-dark feature has been a game changer for those midnight searches—no more fumbling around in the dark! It is the only pacifier her baby will use, and she loves how easy it is to keep them clean. The neutral colour? A bonus that fits seamlessly with all of her baby’s outfits and accessories. After months of daily use, these pacifiers are still going strong without a single issue. Her advice to fellow parents? “Highly recommended for anyone looking for peace of mind and quality!”

Another mom echoed the sentiment, praising both the quality and convenience of the pacifiers. For her, the glow-in-the-dark feature has been a blessing during nighttime searches, and it is the only one her baby consistently accepts. She also appreciates how easy they are to clean and loves that the neutral color complements everything. After months of use, she has zero complaints—just pure satisfaction!

ID: bestnine

Best Pacifier for Reluctant Babies

Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Soother

Best Pacifier for Reluctant Babies
Retailer Image

Why we like it

  • Dishwasher safe
  • Lot of colour options
  • Has a stylish look

Something to Note

  • The handle may be too heavy for some babies
  • The thin silicone may not withstand teething well.

Best for: Newborn, reluctant babies, 

Recommended ages: 0 months and above

Features:  BPA free; PCV free, 2 pack, 

Material Type: 100% food-grade silicone

Customer’s Review

Customer Review: One mom shared her story on how she was hunting for the right pacifier for her little one, especially since her baby has a tongue tie. She tried this silicone newborn pacifier and it was a total game-changer! What stood out to her was the unique shape with a less pronounced tip, which made it incredibly comfortable for her baby to use. The relief she felt when finding something that worked so well was undeniable—it became the perfect fit for her baby’s special needs.

Another mom, who exclusively breastfeeds, found these pacifiers to be the perfect combination of quality and practicality. “Cleaning is a breeze—no spots where water gets trapped, and they dry quickly”. She shared that her babies had no trouble handling these pacifiers from the start, easily getting them into their mouths. For her, the simplicity and reliability of these pacifiers make them a go-to choice every day. She loves that both of her babies are happy with them, and she is confident in recommending them to other moms looking for something durable and baby-approved!

ID: bestten

Best Lovey Pacifier

WubbaNub Pacifier

Best Lovey Pacifier
Retailer Image

Why we like it

  • Machine washable
  • Easy to hold
  • Cute and stays in baby's mouth
  • Dual purpose: a pacifier and comfort object

Something to Note

  • Not suggested for babies in the teething stage
  • Expensive
  • Difficult to clean
  • Available only for ages 0-6 months, with no larger sizes offered.

Best for: Newborn, comfort, tongue-tied babies

Recommended ages: 0-6 months 

Features:  BPA, latex, PCV, phthalate-free, 1 pack, 

Material Type: 100% food-grade silicone

Customer’s Review

Customer Review

Here is a delightful story from one mom who found the perfect pacifier holder for her little one. She calls it a game-changer! The Duck Pacifier Holder quickly became a favorite in their daily routine. Her baby absolutely loves the friendly duck design. It is cute and practical, keeping the pacifier securely in place while still allowing the baby the freedom to spit it out whenever he is ready. This little duck is not just functional; it has become a beloved companion!

Another mom chimed in, saying that balancing comfort and functionality is always her top priority, and this product checks all the boxes. The duck’s gentle grip ensures the pacifier stays put during feeding times, but never feels too restrictive. She describes it as having an extra set of hands, helping to keep everything in order while still respecting her baby’s independence.

What to Look out for While Shopping for a Pacifier

Ultimately, your baby will decide which pacifier they prefer when things get challenging. However, when choosing pacifiers, keep a few key considerations in mind. Consider your baby’s age and whether they are being breastfed or bottle-fed (or your future plans). 

Select a range of pacifiers that match their current feeding experience. If you are breastfeeding, consulting a lactation expert can provide useful recommendations for suitable pacifiers. When evaluating pacifiers, look for the following features. 

Size and age range: When shopping for a pacifier, it is important to consider the appropriate size for your baby’s age. Pacifiers are typically designed with age recommendations to ensure they fit comfortably and safely. Newborn pacifiers are smaller to suit their tiny mouths, while larger sizes are better suited for older babies. It is crucial to select a pacifier that aligns with your baby’s stage of development, as an ill-fitting pacifier can cause discomfort or be less effective in soothing. 

Shape: Pacifier nipples are usually either rounded or flat (orthodontic). Rounded nipples may be easier for babies, especially newborns, to suck on, but they don’t flatten in the mouth like orthodontic nipples, which mimic breastfeeding more closely. Ultimately, the best shape depends on what your baby finds most comfortable.

Materials: Silicone is a popular material for pacifiers due to its softness, flexibility, and safety for all ages. Other options include rubber and latex, and these materials are usually BPA-free.

Design: While a simple design is often sufficient, features like ventilated mouth shields or orthodontic nipples can be advantageous, helping to distinguish one pacifier from another.

Features for specific needs: A pacifier that mimics the breast can be beneficial for breastfed babies. Look for a soft, wide base and a straight nipple, which helps keep the baby’s tongue in a similar position to nursing.

A Note from MindsMaking

A pacifier can provide comfort and meet your baby’s natural urge to suck for reasons other than hunger, aiding in self-soothing. Research indicates that pacifier use may help lower the risk of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS). 

While not essential for every parent or baby, it can be a valuable tool for some families. If you use a pacifier, ensure it is the correct size for your baby’s age and consult your paediatrician for advice. Since babies have individual preferences, trying out multiple pacifier brands and styles can help you find the most suitable one. Our thorough testing and recommendations are designed to guide you in making the best choice for your child.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are pacifiers safe for newborns? +

Can pacifiers help reduce gas? +

Silicone or latex pacifiers, which one is better? +

What is an orthodontic pacifier? +

Is it okay for babies to sleep with pacifiers? +

When should I wean my baby off the pacifier? +

Latest in Mindsmaking

Pregnancy stretch marks, visible on the belly, hips, breasts, and thighs, are common
During pregnancy, some expectant mothers may experience a rise in blood sugar levels
Pregnancy brings excitement and discomfort, including common itching in the hands, feet, and
Congenital anomalies, or birth defects, are structural or functional abnormalities which can manifest
During pregnancy, occasional worries are normal due to hormonal changes, but persistent stress
Early pregnancy often brings breast tenderness, heaviness, and tingling due to increased hormone
No more posts to show

Latest in Mindsmaking

tock Up! Keep multiple pacifiers on hand—stash them in your home, car, and
The first successful IVF birth happened in England in July 1978. Since then,
Babies often suck for comfort, which can confuse parents. Sometimes, they just need
Women with a history of depression have a much higher chance—up to 20
Babies grow rapidly, initially gaining about 1 ounce (28 grams) a day, slowing
No more posts to show